Saturday, June 28, 2014

Do not let custody row adversely affect child: HC

Do not let custody row adversely affect child: Delhi HC


as by Utkarsh Anand : New Delhi, Thu Jan 14 2010

Concerned by the adverse impact custody rows have on children who become mere pawns in the hands of their parents, the Delhi High Court has come up with suggestions not only for couples but also for lawyers, who treat such cases as legal battles to be fought like any other court case.

The judgment, delivered by Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, involved a custody row between two administrative officers, one in the Indian Administrative Services and the other in the Indian Revenue Services, over their 12-year-old child. The visitation rights granted to the girl's father was an issue of contention for the mother, while her father was aggrieved by the girl's custody given to the mother. Both had approached the High Court seeking modification in the lower court order.

Justice Endlaw, however, realised that the parents had least regard towards the impact their differences were having on the child.

"This court can only express regret at such attitude. The parents, even if having mutual differences and incompatibility, have the duty to permit the least impact on the child. The child ought to be permitted to grow with the mutual affection of both parents; the parents ought not to instigate the child against each other and/or to spite the other, ought not to attempt to show the other down in the presence of or through reference before, the child," he said.

Criticising the attitude of the parents, Justice Endlaw said they had forgotten that for the child's development, "love, affection, companionship, guidance" of both parents is essential.

"They forget that their roles as spouses and as parents are entirely different. They allow the same to merge, which can only be to the detriment of the child," he said.

Play positive role, lawyers told
The court also regretted the fact that the Bar was taking up guardianship cases just as any other fiercely contested adversarial litigation.

Calling upon lawyers to play a positive role, the High Court said, "Rather than advising their respective clients to take up accusatory and aggressive positions, they ought to apply a soothing balm to the aching hearts with which the parents reach them."

"Instead of advising their clients that the child should not meet the other parent at all, they should advise them to allow the child to meet and interact with both parents freely and also explain that such an approach bears the imprimatur of the courts. If the members of the Bar play such a constructive role there will be no need to call the children to the courts," it noted.

Passing its order, Justice Endlaw upheld the father's visitation rights in the case and advised the couple that their focus should be to maintain a peaceful environment for the child in both homes to allow full cognitive development.

Source-http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/do-not-let-custody-row-adversely-affect-child-hc/567115/0

Shared Parenting - 6 month child custody in an year to both father and mother.Children who live with their father are more likely to have good physical and emotional health,achieve academically, exhibit self control and pro-social behaviour

Karnataka High Court

K M Vinaya vs B R Srinivas on 13 September, 2013
Author: N.K.Patil And B.Manohar
1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BANGALORE

DATED THIS THE 13TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2013

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE N.K.PATIL

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.MANOHAR

MFA.NO.1729/2011 (G & W)

BETWEEN:

K.M.VINAYA

W/O. B.R.SRINIVAS,

AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS,

R/AT 142, 1ST FLOOR,

15TH MAIN, 3RD STAGE,

4TH BLOCK, BASAVESHWARANAGAR,

BANGALORE - 560 079. .....APPELLANT (BY SMT.LAKSHMI IYENGAR & ASSOCIATES)

AND:

B.R.SRINIVAS,

S/O.B.K.RAMANUJAM,

AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS,

R/AT NO.147, AKKIPET MAIN ROAD,

BANGALORE - 560 053. ...RESPONDENT (BY SMT.M.N.PRABHAMANI, ADVOCATE)

2

MFA FILED U/S 47(c) OF THE GUARDIANS AND

WARDS ACT, AGAINST THE ORDER DT.01.02.2011 PASSED IN G & WC.NO.106/2004 ON THE FILE OF THE III ADDITIONAL PRINCIPAL JUDGE, FAMILY COURT, BANGALORE, ALLOWING THE PETITION FILED U/S 25 OF THE GUARDIAN AND WARDS ACT, FOR CUSTODY OF MINOR SON - VATHAN FROM THE RESPONDENT THEREIN. THIS MFA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED

AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY, B.MANOHAR J., DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

JUDGMENT

Appellant has filed this appeal challenging the legality and correctness of the order dated 01-02-2011 made in G & WC No.106/2004 passed by the III Additional Principal Judge, Family Court at Bangalore directing the appellant herein to hand over custody of the child to the respondent herein.

3

2. The facts of the case are as follows: The respondent-husband had filed a petition under Section 25 of the Guardian and Wards Act, 1890 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act' for short) seeking custody of his minor son, Vathan from the appellant-wife. It is the case of the respondent that the appellant and respondent are the legally wedded husband and wife and their marriage was solemnized on 10-12-1997 at Thirumala Thirupathi Devasthanam Choultry at Bangalore. She entered the matrimonial house on 10-4-1998 after completion of her final year B.Sc examination. She stayed in the matrimonial house up to 5th month of her pregnancy i.e. upto May 2001 and she left the matrimonial house much against the wishes of the respondent and his parents. She gave birth to a male child- Vathan on 13-08-2001. It is the further case of the respondent that during her stay in the matrimonial house, she was looked after very well by him, his parents and other members of the family. She was encouraged by the 4

respondent to prosecute her further studies in computers and to run computer classes and there was no reason for her to leave the matrimonial house during the 5th month of her pregnancy in order to put an end to the matrimonial life. After going to her maternal house, she started giving all pinpricks and treated him with mental and physical cruelty. The respondent was visiting his wife and son at her maternal house almost everyday. During her pregnancy also he was visiting and taking care of her. Four months after the birth of his son, he repeatedly requested her to return to the matrimonial house. However, she refused to come back to the marital house. He also requested his in-laws to advise and send her to the marital house. In spite of repeated requests made by him as well as his parents, the appellant bluntly refused to go back to his marital house. During his visit to her maternal house, he used to shower his love and affection upon his son. Neither the appellant nor her mother and sister tolerated the child coming close to him and getting 5

attached to him. His son had undergone a surgery and medical treatment when he was one year old, which was not disclosed to the respondent or his parents. As the respondent is the natural guardian of his son, he is legally entitled to claim custody of his son and he was deprived of love and affection of his son. The welfare and well-being of the minor son lies with the father. If the child is deprived of his parental love and affection, it will have adverse consequence upon the emotional and psychological development of the child. Before completion of eight months to her son, the appellant got an appointment and she is more interested in her job and to earn money. She has neglected to maintain her son; she leaves the child under the custody of her mother and she works 10 to 12 hours a day and return home late in the night. She also works in the night shifts. She does not have enough time to take care of his minor son. The minor son lost love and affection of mother as well as the father and not growing in a congenial atmosphere. Though the child was 6

suffering from congenital scoliosis the appellant has not given timely treatment. In view of that, the child had to undergo major operation. Due to the negligence on the part of the appellant, the child had to suffer a lot. The respondent is employed in a private company, having his own income and he is in a position to take care of his son and his educational expenditure. He can take care of his son more affectionately, so that the child can grow physically, mentally and emotionally and can be a responsible citizen of the country. It is further alleged that in spite of issuance of legal notice on 9-2-2004 calling upon the appellant to return to the matrimonial house along with the child, she has given reply notice making unfounded allegations against the respondent and deprived him of the love and affection of his son. In view of that, a petition has been filed for custody of the minor child.

3. The appellant herein filed objection to the said petition denying the averments made in the petition, however, 7

admitted the relationship with the respondent and also admitted that the family of the respondent is a joint family. In view of the ill-treatment of the respondent and his family members, she had to leave the matrimonial house during 5th month of her pregnancy. The respondent failed to discharge his duties as a dutiful husband. After the marriage, the appellant learnt that the respondent was in the habit of stealing the household articles and jewels prior to the marriage and it was continued even after the marriage. The creditors of the respondent started harassing the appellant for repayment of loan by using the language undermining the dignity of the appellant. On account of which, the appellant has suffered a lot. After the birth of her son in the year 2001, the respondent remained irresponsible even towards the child and had never taken care of her or the child. In fact, after the birth of the child, the respondent had started doubting the character of the appellant and started ill-treating her both mentally and physically. He was also in the habit of 8

abandoning her and her son and absconding from the place without intimating any one in the family. Once, in the month of August 2002, he had been to Nepal and from there he sent a mail to the appellant requesting her to arrange money for his return journey to Bangalore. On account of intolerable ill- treatment, she started living separately from November 2003 and in order to maintain herself and her son, she got appointed in M.S. Ramaiah Institution. Subsequently she got a job in Progean for maintenance of herself and to up-bring the child since the respondent has failed to take care of them. The respondent is an irresponsible man and he has not generated enough confidence either for her to live with him or for entrusting the custody of the child to him. After Naming Ceremony, he had not visited her house even to see the appellant nor the child. Further, a petition under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act is not maintainable. From the day of birth, the child is under the custody of the appellant and she has taken care of her son, good treatment 9

has been provided and her son is admitted to one of the prestigious schools and he is securing high percentage of marks. Apart from that, she has filed a petition under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act seeking for divorce in M.C.No.1234/2004. The said matter is pending consideration before the II Additional Family Court. Hence, the respondent is not entitled for the custody of minor child and sought for dismissal of the petition.

4. On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the Family Court framed the following points for its consideration: (i) Whether the petitioner is entitled for the custody of the child - Vathan from the

respondent/wife?

(ii) What order?

5. The respondent/petitioner in order to prove his case examined himself as P.W.1 and examined Dr.Mahesh B.H. as P.W.2 and got marked the documents as Ex.P1 to Ex.P56. The appellant/respondent examined herself as R.W.1 and got 10

marked the documents as Ex.R1 to Ex.R93 and also examined Dr.B.S.Shankar as R.W.2.

6. When the said petition is pending before the Family Court, an application for interim custody of the child was filed by the respondent-father. The Family Court had given interim custody of the minor son to the respondent on various dates i.e. on 20-4-2006, 25-4-2009, 7-5-2010, 7-12-2010. Further, on 16-07-2007, visitation right was also given on 1st and 4th Sunday between 3.00 p.m. to 4.00 p.m.

7. The Family Court on considering the oral and documentary evidence let in by the parties and after perusal of the evidence of the doctor who has treated the minor child and also appreciating the opinion of Dr.B.H.Mahesh by an order dated 01-02-2011 allowed the said petition on the ground that the appellant has failed to implement the order dated 15-12-2006 made on I.A.No.19 and she has neglected in taking care of the health of the child. Further the conduct 11

of the appellant clearly shows that she is trying to alienate the child from the father and declared that the respondent/father is entitled for custody of the child-Vathan and directed the appellant/mother to hand over the child to the custody of the respondent within one month. Being aggrieved by the order dated 01-02-2011, the appellant has preferred this appeal.

8. Smt.Lakshmi Iyengar, learned counsel appearing for the appellant contended that the order passed by the family court is contrary to law and evidence on record. The finding recorded by the family court on certain issues is perverse. The family court has proceeded with an erroneous view and came to the wrong conclusion with regard to the custody of the minor child. One of the essential and mandatory ingredients to maintain a petition under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act is that, the person seeking custody of a minor should have had the custody of minor and as such a minor should have been removed from his custody and in 12

the opinion of the Court it must be in the welfare of the minor that the minor should be returned to the custody of the person seeking so. In the present case, the above ingredients have not been satisfied. The family court ought to have dismissed the petition filed seeking for custody of the minor son. It is the contention of the appellant that from the day of birth, her child is under her custody and she has taken care of his health and education. Within one year of the birth of her son, he has undergone an operation in the year 2002. Though the doctor noticed that the child was suffering from congenital lumbar scoliosis, she was informed that there is no problem in his health. Since the child is too young, the said deformity will not grow along with the child. Hence, the doctor did not advise for any operation. In year 2006, the percentage of curvature was only 24% and it was advised by the doctors that by conservative treatment it can be cured. Only in the year 2008, there was substantial increase in the curvature. Then the doctor advised for surgery. The child 13

was examined by more than 12 doctors who are Experts in Spine. Some of the doctors have not suggested for surgery and some had suggested for surgery though it has no adverse effect on the health of the child. After consulting many expert doctors, since the curvature was increased from 24 degrees to 46 degrees, after completion of his examinations in the year 2009, the child underwent operation on 31-3-2010. All necessary care and precautions have been taken with regard to the health of her son. The appellant is more concerned about her son than the respondent. Apart from that, in the year 2009 her son underwent abdominal surgery for Gangrenous Meckel's Dicerticulum with peritonitis in Panacea Hospital. The respondent is an irresponsible man and he has not taken care of his wife and son. In order to take care of her son and herself and for their sustenance, she got appointed in Ramaiah Institute, thereafter she got appointed in Progeon and her working hours is between 1.30 p.m. to 10.30. p.m. The school timings of her son is from 14

8.30 a.m. to 4.30 p.m. She is taking care of her son in the morning hours and prepare him mentally and physically to go to the school. The School records clearly disclose that her son has scored excellent marks and he was participating in extra curricular activities. In spite of the same, the finding of the family court that the appellant has not taken care of the health of the minor child and she does not have sufficient time to take care of her son is erroneous in law. The finding of the family court with regard to parental alienation is contrary to law. From the day of birth, the son is under her care and custody and he is not inclined to go along with his father though she had advised him to go with him. When the appellant's son was under the custody of respondent, he got fractured his leg. The respondent has not taken care of her son from the day of birth of the child in the year 2001 till the year 2004. Only in the year 2004, a legal notice was issued and present petition was filed for custody of the minor son. Since the minor son is not willing to go to the respondent, as 15

per the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the welfare of the minor must be the paramount consideration of the court and not the wishes of the parents who seeks custody or the guardianship of the minor, the court should be concerned with over-all development and healthy environment and physical, emotional, financial support for development, the doctrine of best interest of the child has to be prevailed. Hence the order passed by the family court ignoring the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court is not sustainable and sought for allowing the appeal.

9. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant, to substantiate her case placed reliance on the judgments reported in AIR 2013 SC 102 (Gaytri Bajaj v/s Jiten Bhalla); 2010 AIR SCW 597 (Athar Hussain v/s Syed Siraj Ahmed and Others); AIR (1973) 1 SCC 840 (Rosy Jacob v/s Jacob A Chakramukkal); and AIR(29) 1942 CALCUTTA 215 (Jwala Prasad Saha v/s Bachu Lal Gupta).

16

10. On the other hand, Smt.M.N.Prabhamani, learned counsel appearing for the respondent argued in support of the order passed by the family court and contended that under Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, father is the natural guardian of a minor, however the mother is entitled to custody of the minor who has not completed the age of 5 years. In the instant case, the son of the respondent is aged about more than 12 years. Hence the appellant is not entitled for custody of the minor son. The father is in the constructive custody of the child even though the child is in the actual custody of the mother. In view of that, the petition under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act is maintainable. She further contended that the appellant went to her maternal house for confinement when she was pregnant of 5 months. After the birth of the child, she refused to return back to the marital house. She has deprived her son the love and affection of his father. The respondent being the natural father of the child is entitled to 17

claim custody of his son. As on today, the son has the capacity to understand things and exercise intelligent preference. However, the appellant intentionally alienates the son from the love and affection of his father. She has intentionally not allowed the son to accept the birthday gifts and dresses provided by the respondent and developed hatred in the mind of the son towards his father. The appellant is more interested in her job, earning more money and she has no time to look after the child. She works late in the night and return home only in the midnight. In order to avoid contact of his son, intentionally the son was got admitted to Kumaran's School which is about 20 Kms away from her residence. The child has to leave the school at about 6.45 a.m. The appellant absolutely has no time to take care of the child. Admittedly, the child was suffering spinal deformity from the day of his birth. The radiology report dated 10-7-2002 issued by M.S.Ramaiah Hospital, Bangalore clearly disclose that the child was suffering from Scoliosis of lumbar 18

spine, but no treatment was provided. In the year 2006, the curvature was more than 24 degrees. In the year 2009, it had grown upto 46 degrees. In view of that the child has to undergo major surgery of spine. If the child were to be operated in the year 2004 or 2006 itself by minor operation, the said deformity could have been cured. The congenital scoliosis affects the growth of the child. Against the advice of the doctor, conservative treatment was given to the child for the deformity of spine. The appellant is fond of earning money and she has not taken care of the health and well- being of the child. The family court, on the application I.A.No.19 filed by the respondent, directed the appellant to take the minor child to the Consultant Ortho and Spine Surgeon once in three months for periodical check-up and to submit a report to the court, to show whether there is any change or growth of curvature. In spite of the court direction, she has not submitted the periodical report to the court. Report of the doctors in the year 2006 clearly discloses that 19

Master Vathan is suffering from scoliosis and blocked vertebra. By conservative treatment, the deformity cannot be cured. The report submitted by the doctors was not produced before the court. When the son was under the custody of the respondent, he had taken him to Dr.Mahesh who is an expert surgeon in Spine, wherein the said doctor has opined that the child has to undergo minor operation for deformity of the spine, since there is substantial growth in the curvature and it will hamper the growth of the child. In spite of the opinion of the said doctor, the treatment has not been given to the minor child. After getting the opinion of Dr.Mahesh, many doctors who have seen the MRI scan of the child opined that by conservative treatment, deformity of the spine cannot be cured and recommended for surgery. The doctors at Hosmat Hospital recommended for surgery in the year 2007 itself. The medical certificate issued by Dr.Prakash on the basis of the scanning report of Raghava Diagnostic Center advising for immediate operation was also not taken serious note by the 20

appellant. Many expert doctors who have seen the medical report of the minor son advised to undergo operation. There was significant increase in the throno lumber typhocic from 24 degrees to 40 degrees. Only on 31-3-2010 without informing the respondent she got operated her son in Sparsha Hospital. In the hospital records and also in the school records, the father's name was not mentioned. No information has been given with regard to the major operation of the child. Further she also informed the School authorities not to furnish necessary particulars nor allow the son to meet his father in the school. Intentionally the school has been changed from Venkat International, Rajajinagar to Kumaran's school which is situated more than 20 Kms away from the City to deny the father's love and affection towards his son. Financially also, father is in a position to take care of the son and also his educational expenditure. The respondent is living in the joint family and his sisters' children are also staying along with him. In view of that, the son is having more 21

congenial atmosphere in his residence, whereas the child will be alone along with his maternal grand parents, which would adversely affect the substantial growth of the child. The appellant is purposefully keeping the child away from the father, though the father has equal love and affection towards the child. During the pendency of the petition in the family court, the interim custody was given to the respondent from 2-5-2006 to 8-5-2006, 4-5-2009 to 11-5-2009, 18-5-2010 to 23-05-2010, 16-12-2010 to 12-10-2010. Further visitation right has also been given to the respondent on every second Saturday from 11.00 a.m. to 6.00 p.m. The child has developed love and affection with the father and mingling with the children of respondent's sister. The family court taking note of all these aspects of the matter, held that the child can be developed mentally and physically under the custody of the respondent and on the other hand, the appellant has neglected to take care of the health of the child and her attitude shows that she is trying to alienate the child from his 22

father and passed the order. There is no infirmity or irregularity in the said order. She also relied upon the judgments reported in (2009) 1 SCC 42 (Gaurav Nagpal v/s Sumedha Nagpal), 2004(3) KLJ 458 (Smt.Radha alias Parimala v/s N.Rangappa); 2007(4) CTC 566 (J.Selvan v/s N.Punidha) ; AIR 1996 RAJ 162 (Prakash Chandra Jain v/s Smt.Chandrawati Jain) and sought for dismissal of the appeal.

11. We have carefully considered the arguments addressed by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the orders passed by the family court and also the oral and documentary evidence adduced by the parties.

12. The records clearly disclose that the appellant and respondent are legally wedded wife and husband. The son was born on 13-8-2001 due to their wedlock. The allegation of the husband is that the wife has left the marital house against the wishes of the respondent and his parents and she 23

has not taken care of the health and education of his son. She is trying to alienate the child from his father. She has deprived the love and affection of his son, he being the natural father of the child is entitled to claim custody of his son. The wife has not taken care of the health of the child and she is very much interested in her job. The working hours of the appellant is from 1.30 p.m. to 10.30 p.m., hence she is not in a position to take care of the child. On the other hand, the wife has contended that the husband was in the habit of stealing the household articles and jewels prior to the marriage and the same attitude was continued even after the marriage. He was an irresponsible man and he is in the habit of absconding from the place without intimating anybody and taking loans for his bad habits. After the birth of the child, he has never taken care of his wife and child and he has started doubting her character and ill-treating her both mentally and physically. Hence, the husband is not in a position to take care of the child.

24

13. The respondent/husband in order to prove his case, examined himself as P.W.1 and reiterated the averments made in the petition. In his evidence he deposed that, against the wishes of the husband and other members of his family, the appellant left the marital house when she was five months' pregnant. After the birth of his child, everyday he was visiting his wife and child; however, the appellant, her sister and mother were not tolerating the child coming close to him or getting attached to his father. She bluntly refused to come back to the marital house. The first operation undergone by the child when he was only one year old was not made known to him. The gift articles and cycle given by the father to his child were returned back by the appellant. All the time she is trying to alienate the child from her father. Though the appellant is aware that the child is suffering from congenital scoliosis in the year 2002 itself, no timely treatment was given. Due to that, growth of the child was hampered. In the year 2006 Dr.M.S.Shivaprasad, who has 25

seen the X-ray and scanning reports of the child has given his opinion that the child has to undergo surgery during the summer vacation itself. However, the appellant has not yielded to the advice of the said doctor with regard to the health of the child. She has no time to take care of the health of his son. In view of negligence on the part of the appellant, the child had to undergo major operation in the year 2010. The appellant has not informed anything about the major operation of his son in the year 2010 to the respondent/father. The father being the natural guardian is entitled for custody of his son and he is financially capable of maintaining the educational and other expenditures of his son. There is suitable atmosphere to his son in his house for his sustainable growth.

14. In the cross-examination, he has admitted that till 2004, he was living along with his wife and child. He also deposed that the appellant is trying to alienate the child from him. He has examined Dr.Mahesh B.H, to show that in spite 26

of the advice of the doctor, the timely treatment was not given to the minor child and the deformity in the spine cannot be treated by the conservative treatment and the child has to undergo operation. In support of his case, he got marked the X-ray report, MRI report and opinion of the doctors as Ex.P9 to Ex.P13.

15. The appellant in her evidence reiterated her defense and deposed that due to the harassment by the husband and his family members, she has to leave the matrimonial house and was under the mercy of her father, who is a retired government employee. She has admitted that her husband is residing in the joint family along with his aunts. In the cross-examination she has deposed that she has given best treatment to her son who was suffering from congenital scoliosis. Dr.Shankar, who has treated her son stated that the deformity can be cured by conservative treatment and immediate operation is not required since the curvature is only 24 degrees. There is no progress in the curvature and it 27

will not come in the way of growth of the child. In the year 2006, she got done the scanning and X-ray of spine of her son and there was no much progress in the curvature and as per the advice of the doctors, she has given treatment to her son. Her son was examined by the doctors at Hosmat Hospital, Manipal Hospital, Mallige Medical Center and other doctors who are experts in the field. Only in the year 2009, there was progress in the curvature. Dr.C.B.Prabhu, who has seen the X-ray and Scanning reports of her son advised for operation. Accordingly, her son had undergone operation on 31-3-2010. All possible care has been taken to treat her son and there is no negligence on her part. From the day of birth, the child is under the custody of the appellant and no attachment has been developed with the respondent and her son has refused to go with the respondent/father. She has denied the allegations with regard to the alienation of the child from the father.

28

16. In support of her case, she examined Dr.B.S.Shankar, who is an orthopedic surgeon. In his evidence he deposed that the deformity in the spine will not affect the day to day activities and the growth of the child. There is no progress of curvature from 2002 to 2008. Accordingly, he had advised for conservative treatment. Since the child was too young, he did not suggest for surgery at that young age.

17. The evidence on record clearly discloses that the appellant has taken due care of her minor son. She has given all possible treatment as per the advice of the doctors. Initially, she had given treatment to her son in M.S. Ramaiah Hospital, thereafter, her son was taken for periodical scanning and X-rays at Padmashree and Raghav Diagnostic Centers. Dr.Shankar who has treated her son has advised for the conservative treatment since there was no progress in the curvature. During the year 2006, the curvature was only 24 degrees and there was some increase in the curvature from 24 to 26 degrees in the year 2007. Dr.C.B.Prabhu, after 29

examining the X-Ray and Scanning reports, opined that the child has multiple lumbar vertebra, 1, 2, 3 and 4 are the hemi vertebra. The doctor advised that the child requires surgery. The other doctors at Manipal Hospital who have treated the minor child opined that immediate surgery is not required. The deformity in the spine has not come in the way of natural growth except that the child does not have any other complaint, either of back or leg pain. Only in the year 2009, the percentage of development of curvature was increased from 26 degrees to 40 degrees. As per the advice of the doctor, treatment was given in the best hospitals in the State. After the operation, her son is doing well and he is participating in extra-curricular activities. The respondent has also not disputed with regard to the treatment given. The only allegation is that the operation ought to have been conducted in the year 2006 itself. It is difficult to appreciate the contention of the respondent. The mother also has the very same concern about her son. The records clearly disclose 30

that she has given best treatment to her son and periodical check up is also made. However, she has failed to report the same to the Court as per the order on 15-12-2006. The family court, while passing the order on I.A.No.19 clearly directed the appellant to submit the report once in three months, to state whether there is any change or growth in the curve. Since there was no change in the curve, she has not submitted the report. The child has undergone operation in the year 2002 and 2009 and also major operation of the spine on 31-3-2010. The Scanning reports clearly disclose that sufficient care has been taken by the appellant. It is difficult to accept the finding of the family court that the appellant is negligent in taking care of the health of her child.

18. The records produced by the appellant clearly disclose that she has taken sufficient care in respect of education of her son. For the purpose of better education, the child was admitted in Kumaran's School which was situated near Silk Board and now it has been shifted to the new Campus. The 31

progress reports clearly disclose that the child has secured excellent marks and also participating in extra curricular activities.

19. Both the appellant as well as the respondent are financially capable of taking care of their child. The appellant is working in Progeon Company and the working hours is from 1.30 p.m. to 10.30 p.m. One hour is required for travelling from the office to her residence. Her office is having holidays on Saturdays and Sundays. The specific case of the appellant is that, in the morning hours as well as on Saturdays and Sundays, she is taking care of her son. During her absence, her son will be with her parents and they are also educated and can take care of her son. The respondent is also working in a Private Company and his working hours is from 5.30 a.m. to 2.30 p.m. He also claims that he can devote more time towards his son and he is in a position to take care of medical and educational expenditure of his son. Further, on an application filed by the appellant 32

seeking for educational and medical expenditures, the respondent has paid sum of Rs.1,72,000/- towards the medical and educational expenditures. He claims that he is staying in a joint family, his brother and sister's children are also staying with him. There is congenial atmosphere for sustainable growth of his son. On the other hand, the child has to stay alone, along with the appellant's age old parents which would affect the over-all development of the child.

20. With regard to the parental alienation is concerned, admittedly the appellant has filed M.C.No.1234/2004 seeking for divorce against her husband. From the day of birth of her son, he is under the custody of the appellant. She has taken care of the medical and educational expenditure. The respondent has not spent any money towards his son till the court passed the order directing him to pay medical and educational expenditures of his son on 25-4-2009. In view of that, she has refused to accept the birthday gifts given to her son by the respondent. That itself cannot be treated as 33

parental alienation. Apart from that the interim custody of the minor son was also given to the respondent as per various orders passed by the family court on 20-4-2006, 25-4-2009, 7-5-2010, 15-12-2010. The visitation right was also given. During the pendency of this appeal, interim custody has been given as per the orders dated 21-4-2011, 25-11-2011, 25-12-2011, 16-04-2012 and 11-12-2012. Further the visitation right was also given as per the order dated 28-07-2011. Hence, the finding of the family court that the appellant is trying to alienate the child from his father cannot be acceptable.

21. The records clearly disclose that the respondent is also having utmost love and affection towards his son. From the last eight years, he is litigating for his son, which shows that he has great love and affection for him. The child is aged about 12 years as on today. The child is not capable of expressing any intelligent preference. In view of the interim custody of the child, the child has acquaintance with both the 34

family. He can stay along with the family members of the father as well as the mother. The respondent has paid more than Rs.1,72,000/- towards medical and educational expenditure of his son. Hence, the respondent can also take care of his son as the appellant is taking. Under Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, father is the natural guardian, however, the custody of a minor who has not completed the age of 5 years shall ordinarily be with the mother. Thereafter, the father is also entitled for custody of the child.

22. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in various judgments held the welfare of the child as paramount consideration while determining the issues relating to the custody of the child. There should be a proper balance between the rights of the respective parents and the welfare of the child. The moral and ethical welfare of the child must also weigh with the court as well as its physical well being. The child requires love and affection of both father and mother. The Hon'ble 35

Supreme Court further held that the court has to give due weightage to the child's ordinary contentment, health, education, intellectual development and favourable surrounding, but over and above physical comforts. When the court is confronted with the conflicting demands made by the parents, the court has not only to look at the issue on legalistic basis, but human angles are also relevant for deciding such issues. The object and purpose of the Act is not merely physical custody of the minor, but due protection of the right of the Ward, health, maintenance and education.

23. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the judgment reported in AIR 2013 SC 102 (supra) has observed that an order of custody of minor children is required to be made by the Court treating the interest and welfare of the minor to be the paramount importance. It is not the better right of either parent that would require adjudication while deciding their entitlement to custody. The desire of the child coupled with the availability of a conducive and appropriate environment 36

for proper upbringing together with the ability and means of the concerned parent to take care of the child are some of the relevant factors that have to be taken into account by the court while deciding the issue of custody of the minor. What must be emphasized is that while all other factors are undoubtedly relevant, it is the desire, interest and welfare of the minor which is crucial and ultimate consideration that must guide the determination required to be made by the court.

24. In order to ascertain the desire of the child, personal interaction was made in our Chamber. The child expressed his desire to go along with his mother which may be due to the pressure of the mother or that the child is all along with the mother and also that the child is only 12 years old. The evidence of the parties clearly discloses that both the appellant as well as the respondent are in a position to take care of the minor child. Admittedly, the respondent is residing in the joint family along with his parents, brother and sister's 37

children. The child can grow in the warmth atmosphere of the joint family. It will help in the sustainable growth of the child, whereas the minor has to stay alone with his maternal grand parents in the appellant's house. The father is a friend, philosopher and guide to the child. The overall development of the child can be possible with the love and affection of the father. No allegation has been made regarding ill-treatment of the child in the father's house and congenial atmosphere is available in the house of the respondent for the sustainable growth and grooming of the child.

25. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in a judgment reported in 2008 AIR SCW 4043 in the case of Mausami Moitra Ganguli V/S Jayant Ganguli held as under:

"The principles of law in relation to the

custody of a minor child are well settled. It is trite that while determining the question as to which parent the care and control of a child should be committed, the first and the paramount consideration is the welfare and interest of the child 38

and not the rights of the parents under a statute. Indubitably the provisions of law pertaining to the custody of child contained in either the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 (Section 17) or the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 (Section 13) also hold out the welfare of the child are predominant consideration. In fact, no statute on the subject, can ignore, eschew or obliterate the vital factor of the welfare of the minor. The question of welfare of the minor child has again to be considered in the back ground of the relevant facts and circumstances. Each case has to be decided on its own facts and other decided cases can hardly serve as binding precedents insofar as the factual aspects of the case are concerned. It is, no doubt, true that father is presumed by the statutes to be better suited to look after the welfare of the child, being normally the working member and head of the family, yet in each case the Court has to see primarily to the welfare of the child in determining the question of his or her custody. Better financial resources of either of the parents or their love for the child may be one of the relevant considerations but cannot be the sole determining 39

factor for the custody of the child. It is here that a heavy duty is cast on the Court to exercise its judicial discretion judiciously in the background of all the relevant facts and circumstances, bearing in mind the welfare of the child as the paramount consideration."

26. The Hon'ble Supreme Court had an occasion to consider the legal position regarding the father's right for the custody of the child vis-à-vis the welfare of the minor in : Rosy Jacob V/S A.Chakramukkal case reported in AIR 1973 SC 2090 and it has been held as under:

"In our opinion, the dominant consideration for making orders under Section 25 is the welfare of the minor children and in considering this question, due regard, of course, has to be paid to the right of the father to be the guardian and, also, to all other relevant factors having a bearing on the minor's welfare............. The father's fitness has to be considered, determined and weighed pre- dominantly in terms of the welfare of his minor children in the context of all the relevant circumstances. If the custody of the father cannot 40

promote their welfare equally or better than the custody of the mother then, he cannot claim indefeasible right to their custody under Section 25 merely because there is no defect in his personal character and he has attachment for the children - which every normal parent has ...... The father's fitness from the point of view just mentioned cannot override consideration of the welfare of the minor children. No doubt, the father has been presumed by the statute generally to be better fitted to look after the children - - being normally the earning member and head of the family - - but the Court has, in each case, to see primarily to the welfare of the children in determining the question of their custody, in the background of all the relevant facts having a bearing on their health, maintenance and education."

27. The appellant has produced the latest report from Dr.Gowrishankar of BGS Hospital which clearly discloses that the minor son is maintaining very good health and he is taking participation in the extra curricular activities, sports and games. He is also one of the participants of the Football 41

team in the school. As on today, he is aged about 12½ years and reaching the age of adolescence. At this stage, the guidance and friendliness of the father is also required. The minor child is living with the appellant from the day of his birth and she has taken care of the well-being of the child with love and affection that by itself would not entitle her the custody of child. Father's care and love has a powerful and positive impact upon the development and health of a child. In addition, numerous studies have found that children who live with their father are more likely to have good physical and emotional health to achieve academically and more likely to exhibit self control and pro-social behaviour. It is important that the minor has his father's care and guidance, at this formative and impressionable stage of his life. Nor can the role of the father in his upbringing and grooming to face the realities of life be undermined. It is in that view father's care is important for the child's healthy growth. Parental touch and influence of other parent will enable the two to stay in 42

touch and share moments of joy, learning and happiness with each other. Hence, we are of the opinion that both the appellant and respondent are entitled for custody of the child for the sustainable growth of the minor child. We are of the view that the minor son shall be given under the custody of the respondent from 1st January to 30th June and under the custody of the appellant from 01st July to 31st December every year and they shall take care of the well-being and education of the minor son till he attains the age of majority. The education and other expenditure have to be shared equally by the appellant and respondent. Both will have visitation right on every Saturday and Sunday. When the minor is under the custody of the appellant she shall not prevent telephonic contact between the father and the son or video conferencing between the two if it is possible. She should not induce hatred towards father in the mind of minor child, though there are differences between the husband and wife. After the minor son attaining majority, it is open for him to take his 43

own decision. This arrangement will not affect the interest of the child, since the child is acquainted with the family members of his father due to interim custody, during the pendency of the petition before the family court as well as the appeal before this court. Apart from that on the basis of the joint memo filed by the parties, the custody of the child was given to the respondent/father during Deepavali festival. Some of the judgments relied upon by both the parties is not applicable to the facts of the present case. Hence, the order passed by the family court is required to be modified. Accordingly, we pass the following:

ORDER

The appeal is allowed in part. The order dated 1-2-2011 made in G & WC 106/2004 passed by the III Additional Principal Judge Family Court, Bangalore is modified. The respondent/father is entitled to the custody of the minor child from 01st January to 30th June and the appellant/mother is entitled to custody of the child from 01st July to 31st 44

December of every year, till the minor son attains the age of majority.

The appellant and respondent are directed to maintain education and other expenditures of their son in equal proportion and both will have visitation rights during Saturdays and Sundays. The minor child shall be allowed to use the telephone or video conference with father or mother, as the case many be.

Sd/-

Judge

Sd/-

Judge

mpk/-*

Monday, June 23, 2014

Delhi court sends strong message - Girl and Women to face legal consequences for falsely accusing and fabricating false evidence

Delhi court sends strong message - Girl and Women to face legal consequences for falsely accusing and fabricating false evidence 

While digging http://judis.nic.in/ found out that in the fast track Delhi court for POCSO (Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act) majority ~90% cases were false and girls (less than 18 years old) and their mothers or sisters are blatantly abusing the POCSO. This Special law (POCSO) is also being misused and abused freely by women (including Girls) folk to settle the personal score and for oblique motives and is turning out to be another weapon of Legal Terrorism. 

Truely Feminism in India has trained Girls to become a part of Legal Terrorism network. 

There were other cases where the judge pulled Police for the Shoody investigation which shall be posted soon.

Interesting Media is not highlighting these cases for reasons known to all !

Men and Boys wake up !
-----

IN THE COURT OF SH. PAWAN KUMAR JAIN
ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-01 (CENTRAL): DELHI
SC No. : 194/13
ID No. : 02401R0596392013
FIR No.   : 87/13
Police Station : Gulabi Bagh
Under Section : 323/354/506/34 IPC 
r/w Section 8 POCSO
State 
Versus
Karnail Singh
S/o Late Sh. Suraj Pal
R/o 10613, Gali No. 5
Pratap Nagar, Delhi
.........Accused No. 1
Deepa
W/o Karnail Singh
R/o 10613, Gali No. 5
Pratap Nagar, Delhi
.........Accused No. 2
Date of Institution  : 21.11.2013
Date of judgment  :  19.05.2014
Present:  Sh. R.K. Tanwar, Additional Public Prosecutor for the 
State.
Sh. Sachin Aggarwal, Advocate for Mr. Jitender Sethi, 
Advocate, counsel for both the accused persons.
J U D G M E N T (ORAL) : - 
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 1of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
1.                   Briefly stated facts of prosecution case are that on July 03,
2013 at about 9 PM, complainant (PW1) along with her two sisters, namely,
PW2 and PW3 came to the police station Gulabi Bagh and lodged a
complaint with duty officer that accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa
had beaten them. Said intimation was recorded vide DD 21A (Ex.PW10/C).
Constable Anjela was directed to record the statement of complainant
(PW1) and thereafter DD No. 21A was assigned to SI Vijay. ( since the
complainant and her sisters are victim of sexual assault, their identity is
withheld and they are referred to as PW1, PW2 and PW3). 
2.                   It was alleged that complainant (PW1) got recorded her
statement Ex.PW1/B wherein she alleged that on July 03, 2013 at about 8
PM, she along with her two sisters, namely, PW2 and PW3 was going to
doctor's clinic as her sister PW3 had sustained burn injury on July 02,
2013. It was alleged that when they reached near Temple opposite to gali
No. 6, accused Karnail Singh, who resided in their neighbourhood came
there and started teasing her and passed indecent gestures and when
complainant protested, accused Karnail Sinigh scratched her mouth and
when her sister (PW2) raised objection, accused Karnail Singh had torn her
salwar. It was alleged that when her another sister (PW3) raised objection,
accused Karnail Singh hit on her chest and torn her suit from front side. It
was further alleged that in the meantime Deepa wife of Karnail Singh also
came there and both of them started beating complainant and her sisters. It
was alleged that accused Karnail Singh had threatened if report be lodged
to the police, he would kill complainant and her sisters. It was further
alleged that earlier also Karnail Singh had made several attempts to tease
her. Complainant and her sisters were got medically examined.
Complainant was found sustaining blunt injury whereas no fresh injury was
found on the person of PW2. On her statement, an FIR for the offence
punishable under Section 323/354/354A/354B/509/34 Indian Penal Code
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 2of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
(IPC in short) was got registered. During investigation, statement of PW2
and PW3 was also got recorded under Section 161 Code of Criminal
Procedure (Cr. P.C. in short). Their torn clothes were seized. During
investigation, statement of all the victims were got recorded under Section
164 Cr. P.C. It was alleged that since PW2 was found minor, provisions of
Section 8 of Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO in
short) was also added. 
3.                   It was alleged that accused Deepa w/o Karnail Singh was
granted anticipatory bail on July 15, 2013. On October 21, 2013, accused
Karnail Singh was arrested. He was found involved in numerous other
cases. 
4.                   After investigation, challan was filed against accusd Karnail
Singh for the offence punishable under Section 323/354/354B/509/506/34
Indian Penal Code and under Section 8 of Protection of Children from
Sexual Offence Act whereas accused Deepa was challaned for the offence
punishable under Section 323 of IPC. 
5.                   Aftercomplying with the provisions of Section 207 Code of
Criminal Procedure, a charge for the offence punishable under Section
354/354A/354B/324/506 IPC read with Section 8 of POCSO Act was
framed against the accused Karnail Singh whereas a separate charge
against both the accused persons for the offence punishable under Section
323/34 IPC was framed, to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. 
6.                   In order to bring home the guilt of accused, prosecution has
examined as many as following 10 witnesses. 
PW1          Complainant, material witness but turned hostile.
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 3of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
PW2          Sister of complainant, material witness but turned 
hostile.
PW3          Sister of complainant, material witness but turned 
hostile.
PW4          Geeta, neighbour, material witness but turned 
hostile.
PW5          SI Vimal Dutt, second investigating officer.
PW6          Kamlesh, material witness but turned hostile.
PW7          Uncle of complainant (in order to conceal the 
identity of victim, his identity is also withheld )
PW8          Father of victims (in order to conceal the 
identity of victims, his identity is also withheld )
PW9          Smt. Siksha Devi, neighbour, material witness but 
turned hostile.
PW10        SI Vijay Investigating officer.
7.                   Inview of the testimony of material witnesses, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor closed the prosecution evidence on May 09,
2014. 
8.                   Since, there is no incriminating evidence against the accused
persons, their examination under Section 313 of Cr. P.C. was dispensed
with.
9.                   Learnedcounsel appearing for the accused persons
sagaciously contended that though prosecution has examined all the
material witnesses, yet none of the witnesses has uttered even a single
word against the accused persons. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor
fairly conceded that the testimony of material witnesses examined by
prosecution are not sufficient to prove the culpability of accused persons as
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 4of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
all the material witnesses turned hostile. However, he submitted that
suitable action should be taken against the complainant and her sisters
who have resiled from their previous statements made on oath under
Section 164 Cr. P.C. 
10.                 I have heard rival submissions advanced by counsel for both
the parties, perused the record carefully and gave my thoughtful
consideration to their contentions. 
11.                 Prosecutionhas set up a case against the accused persons
that when complainant along with her sisters was going to doctor's clinic on
July 03, 2013, accused Karnail Singh met them on the way near Temple
opposite to gali No. 6 and thereafter he passed indecent gestures towards
complainant and when she raised objection, he scratched on her mouth
and when her sister PW2 raised objection, accused Karnail Singh torn her
salwar and when her another sister PW3 raised objection, accused Karnail
Singh torn her kamiz from front side. In the meantime, Deepa wife of
accused Karnail Singh also joined him and thereafter they gave beating to
the complainant and her sisters. However, when complainant PW1 and her
sisters PW2 and PW3 graced the witness box, they all turned hostile
completely and did not support the prosecution case in any manner.
Though, complainant and her sisters were examined at length by learned
Additional Public Prosecutor, yet during their cross-examination nothing
could be extracted which may help the prosecution to prove the culpability
of accused persons. Thus, the testimony of PW1, PW2 and PW3 are not
helpful to the prosecution to prove the culpability of accused persons. 
12.                 Prosecutionhas also set up a case that PW4, PW6 and
PW9 also reached the spot after hue and cry and they also witnessed the
said incident but all the said witnesses also turned hostile completely and
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 5of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
did not support the prosecution case in any manner. Admittedly, PW7 and
PW8 were not the eye witnesses and they came to know about the incident
later on. Thus, their testimony is not helpful to the prosecution to prove the
culpability of accused persons. Moreover, both the witnesses also turned
hostile completely and did not support the prosecution case in manner. 
13.                 Remainingwitnesses are PW5 SI Vimal Dutt to whom further
investigation was assigned and PW10 who conducted the investigation. In
view of the fact that material witnesses turned hostile completely and they
did not support the prosecution in any manner, their testimony is also not
helpful to prosecution to prove the guilt of accused persons.
14.                 Fromthe aforesaid discussion, it becomes abundantly clear
that there is no iota of evidence against the accused persons, thus,
prosecution has miserably failed to bring home the guilt of accused
persons, thus, I acquit both the accused persons from all the charges. 
15.                 Now, coming to the next contention raised by learned
Additional Public Prosecutor as to whether it is a fit case to take legal
action against the complainant and her sisters. 
16.                 Itis undisputed fact that during investigation complainant and
her sisters made statement on oath under Section 164 Code of Criminal
Procedure and their statements are Ex.PW1/A, Ex.PW2/A and Ex.PW3/C
respectively. 
17.                 PW1complainant lodged an FIR against the accused
persons by making her statement Ex.PW1/B that when she along with her
sisters, namely, PW2 and PW3 reached near Temple opposite to gali No.
6, accused Karnail Singh S/o Suraj Pal, R/o 10613, Gali No. 5, Pratap
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 6of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
Nagar, Delhi who resided in her neighbourhood came in front of her and
started teasing her and passed indecent gestures and when she raised
objection, accused Karnail Singh scratched her mouth and when her sister
PW2 raised objection, accused Karnail Singh torn her salwar and when her
another sister PW3 raised objection, accused Karnail Singh hit on her
chest and torn her suit (shirt) from front side. In the meantime, Deepa wife
of accused Karnail Singh also came there and she also started beating
them. It was further alleged that accused Karnail Singh had threatened
them, if complaint was made to the police, he would kill the complainant
and her sisters and further alleged that previously also accused Karnail
Singh had made several attempts to tease her. Thus, from her complaint
Ex.PW1/B, it becomes clear that complainant and her sisters knew
accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa previously. Similarly,
complainant in her statement under Section 164 Cr. P.C. (Ex.PW1/A) made
specific allegations against the accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa.
Similarly her sisters i.e.PW2 and PW3 in their statement recorded under
Section 164 Cr. P.C., which are exhibited as Ex.PW2/A and Ex.PW3/C
respectively made specific allegations against both the accused persons. 
18.                 Frombare perusal of the FIR and the statement of witnesses
recorded under Section 164 Cr. P.C., it can be culled-out that they knew
the accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa previously. However, when
complainant appeared in the witness box, she turned hostile completely by
deposing that when they reached near Mandir outside their gali, there was
no light in the area and some boys came there along with 2-3 girls and they
were abusing them and when they raised objection, they started scuffling
with her, consequently, she sustained injury on her cheek. She further
deposed that when scuffling took ugly turn, they had also started scuffling
with her sisters (PW2 and PW3) and in the said scuffling, shirt and salwar
of her sisters (PW2 and PW3) were torn. She further deposed that since
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 7of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
there is no electricity in the area, she could not see the face of that persons
and females and further deposed that she was not sure whether she could
identify anyone of them or not. She further deposed that they did not inform
the police; rather someone from public made a call to police and further
deposed that she did not go to the police station along with her sisters and
further deposed that on the next day they went to police station and at that
time she was accompanied with her Bua and her sisters. She further
deposed that someone from crowd told her that probably Karnail Singh and
his wife Deepa were among the assailants and further deposed that she
did not give any statement to the police. She further testified that no one
had given any threat either to her or to her sisters. During crossexamination conducted by learned Additional Public Prosecutor, she
deposed that she did not know Karnail Sinigh. However, stated that she
knew his wife Deepa and admitted that she is residing in her
neighbourhood. She failed to identify the accused Karnail Singh. She
categorically denied the prosecution version that accused Karnail Singh
and his wife Deepa were the assailants. She admitted that none had given
any threat her either today or previously and she was not under any
pressure. She further deposed that she did not know whether on the basis
of her complaint Ex.PW1/B and statement made under Section 164 Code
of Criminal Procedure (Ex.PW1/A), accused Karnail Singh and his wife
Deepa were arrested and further deposed that she did not know whether
any other person was arrested on basis of her above said complaint and
statement. She further deposed that police did not inform her about the
action taken on her complaint. 
19.                 Fromthe deposition of PW1, it becomes clear that she had
completely resiled from her complaint Ex.PW1/B and the statement made
under Section 164 Cr. P.C. (Ex.PW1/A). On the contrary, she tried to set
up new case that she had disclosed the name of accused Karnail Singh
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 8of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
and his wife Deepa because some unknown person told her that probably
they were the assailants but she could not see the face of assailants due
to darkness in the area. Similarly, PW2 also turned hostile stating that
there was no electricity in the area and scuffled had taken place with 2-3
boys and her salwar was torn during the scuffle. Similarly, shirt of her sister
(PW3) was also torn during the scuffle and further deposed that none had
torn their clothes. She admitted that no threat was given to her and also
admitted that she had made a statement Ex.PW2/A under Section 164 Cr.
P.C. During cross-examination conducted by learned Additional Public
Prosecutor, she stated that she did not know any person by the name of
Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa and she failed to identify both the
accused persons. Though she admitted that she had made allegations
against the accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa in her statement
under Section 164 Cr. P.C. but stated that she had made allegations
against them at the instance of police because police advised them to
make allegations against the accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa
because public persons told the police that assailants might be Karnail
Singh and his wife Deepa. When a court question was put to her, she
admitted that she had made false allegations against the accused Karnail
Singh and his wife Deepa in her statement under Section 164 Cr. P.C.
(Ex.PW2/A) but took the plea that she did so as she could not see
assailants and public persons told her that assailants were Karnail Singh
and his wife Deepa. However, when a question was put to her whether she
could tell the name of public persons who told her about the same, she
replied that she cannot tell their name. She also stated that she did not
inform learned Metropolitan Magistrate that she had made allegations
against accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa at the instance of
unknown public persons or police officials. She deposed that she did not
know whether police had arrested Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa on the
basis of her statement and statement of her sisters made to the police.
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 9of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
However, she admitted that no threat was given to her. 
20.                 Fromher testimony, it becomes clear that she had impleaded
accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa at the instance of some
unknown persons and none had torn their clothes but the same were torn
during scuffle with some unknown persons. It is also clear that accused
Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa were not responsible for the alleged
incident. 
21.                 Similarly, PW3 turned hostile completely by deposing that
the quarrel had taken place with 6-7 persons and 2-3 ladies and in that
process someone had pushed complainant and scratched on her face. In
the meantime, some ladies assaulted her and her sisters (PW1 and PW2)
and in that process her shirt and salwar of her sister was torn. Police also
came there and she also admitted that she had made a statement under
Section 164 Cr. P.C. (Ex.PW3/A). During cross-examination conducted by
learned Additional Public Prosecutor, she stated that she did not know the
accused Karnail Singh and failed to recognise him. She also denied the
suggestions that accused Karnail Singh had torn her shirt or salwar of her
sister or he also scratched the mouth of complainant. She also denied that
Deepa was was involved in the incident. She admitted that she was not
under any threat from any corner. She admitted that she had named
Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa in her statement Ex.PW3/C and admitted
that she had made false allegations against them in her statement under
Section 164 Cr. P.C. but took the plea that she did so because public
persons told her that assailants were Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa and
further admitted that she made allegations against them before police at
the instance of said public persons but stated that she cannot tell their
name. She further stated that she did not know whether accused Karnail
Singh and his wife Deepa were arrested by the police on the basis of her
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 10of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
statement and on the statement of her sisters. She further stated that she
told the police that she had disclosed the name of Karnail Singh and his
wife Deepa at the instance of unknown person but she did not disclose this
fact before the learned Metropolitan Magistrate. 
22.                 Asper statement of PW1, PW2 and PW3, the alleged
incident had taken place on July 03, 2013 at about 8 PM. DD No. 21A
(Ex.PW10/C) was got recorded by complainant at 9.06 PM wherein
complainant had categorically named the accused Karnail Singh and his
wife Deepa. Thereafter, her statement was recorded by Constable Anjela
and in her statement Ex.PW1/B, she had made specifically allegations
against the accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa and further alleged
that accused Karnail Singh was residing in her neighbourhood. Similarly,
PW2 and PW3 also made specific allegations against the accused Karnail
Singh and his wife Deepa. But when they entered the witness box, PW1,
PW2 and PW3 took the plea that they made allegations against the
accused Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa at the instance of unknown
public person as they could not see the face of assailants as there was
darkness in the area and public persons told them that probably the
assailants were Karnail Singh and his wife Deepa. Admittedly, this fact was
not disclosed by any of them either before police or before learned
Metropolitan Magistrate. If they had not seen the assailants, it was their
duty to inform the police that though they had not seen the assailants, yet
public persons told them the assailants might be Karnail Singh and his wife
Deepa. But complainant and her sisters failed to state so. Rather they
made specific allegations against the accused persons. Thus, it become
clear that either PW1, PW2 and PW3 have made a false statement before
this Court or they have made a false statement on oath before the learned
Metropolitan Magistrate under Section 164 Cr. P.C. 
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 11of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another
23.                 Falseevidence is defined under Section 191 Indian Penal
Code whereas fabricating false evidence is defined under Section 192
Indian Penal Code. Both are reproduced as under:
191. Giving false evidence– Whoever, being
legally bound by an oath or by an express
provision of law to state the truth, or being bound
by law to make a declaration upon any subject,
makes any statement which is false, and which
he either knows or believes to be false or does
not believe to be true, is said to give false
evidence.
Explanation 1.- A statement is within the
meaning of this section, whether it is made
verbally or otherwise. 
Explanation 2. - A false statement as to the
belief of the person attesting is within the
meaning of this section, and a person may be
guilty of giving false evidence by stating that he
believes a thing which he does not believe, as
well as by stating that he knows a thing which he
does not know.
192. Fabricating false evidence– Whoever
causes any circumstances to exist or [makes any
false entry in any book or record, or electronic
record or makes any document or electronic
record containing a false statement], intending
that such circumstances, false entry or false
statement may appear in evidence in a judicial
proceeding, orin a proceeding taken by law
before a public servantas such, or before an
arbitrator, an that such circumstances, false entry
or false statement, so appearing in evidence may
cause any person who in such proceeding is to
form an opinion upon the evidence, to entertain
an erroneous opinion touching any point material
to the result of such proceeding, is said “to
fabricate false evidence”. 
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 12of 15State Vs Karnail Singh & another

24. As already stated that PW1, PW2 and PW3 either made false evidence before this Court or before learned Metropolitan Magistrate on oath under Section 164 Cr. P.C. Prima-facie their act amounts giving false evidence and fabricating false evidence as defined under Section 191 and 192 IPC. Indisputably, statements before learned Metropolitan Magistrate under Section 164 Cr. P.C. and the complaint Ex.PW1/B were made within an intention that the same shall be used during judicial proceeding against the accused persons, thus prima-facie complainant and her sisters (PW2 and PW3) have committed an offence punishable under Section 193 IPC.

25.                 Nowquestion arises as to whether proceeding can be
initiated against the PW2 who was 17 years 9 months and 6 days old at the
time of alleged incident. As per record, her date of birth is October 28,
1995. Thus, she was minor a the time of incident but she was major when
she appeared in the witness box on April 24, 2014. Since, the offence was
committed on April 24, 2014 when she resiled from her previous statement,
thus, to my mind, there is no bar under law to proceed against her.

26. Nodoubt, under Section 22 of POCSO Act, no action can be taken against a child if child makes a false complaint or provides false information. To my mind, police cannot take any action against any child, if during investigation, it is revealed that the child had made a false complaint or information provided by him/her is false. But this does not empowers a child to make a false deposition in judicial proceeding. This further clears from Section 22 (1) of POCSO Act because the maximum sentence to furnish false information is up to six months or with a fine or both whereas to make a false statement on oath before the Court and to give false evidence or fabricate false evidence is punishable for imprisonment which may extend upto 7 years. This further makes it clear that Section 22 of POCSO Act does not empowers a child witness to make a false statement in judicial proceeding. Thus, I am of the view that Section 22 of the POCSO Act does not prevent the Court in any manner from proceeding even against the child witness, if there are sufficient reasons to believe that the child witness has made a false evidence or created a false or fabricated circumstance. At the cost of repetition, it is pointed out that in instant case PW2 was not a child at the time when she graced the witness box on April 24, 2014. 



27.                 Itis pertinent to mention here that accused Karnail Singh was
arrested by the police on October 21, 2013 and he was released on bail on
December 21, 2013, thus, he remained in jail for two months on the basis
of allegations made by complainant and her sisters and now they very
easily stated they had made allegations against him at the instance of
some unknown persons. Thus, it becomes clear that accused Karnail Singh
has been deprived from his personal liberty for about two months on the
basis of allegations levelled by the complainant and her sisters. 

28. Needlessto say that witnesses play a significant role in the administration of criminal justice. If witnesses be permitted to behave in such a irresponsible manner, it will become just impossible for courts to impart justice. If they (PW1 to PW3) have settled their dispute with accused persons out of the Court, they should have approached the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in accordance with law for quashing of proceedings instead of making a false statement before the Court. It is pertinent to state that witnesses did not depose that they have settled the dispute with the accused persons. If witnesses like PW1, PW2 and PW3 are not checked or dealt with sternly wrong message would disseminate among public at large that witnesses can take somersault during trial at any point of time as per their whims and fancies without facing any consequences, thus, I am of the considered opinion that PW1, PW2 and PW3 deserve to face the consequences of their wrongful act. 

29. Inview the above discussion, I am of the considered opinion that prima-facie there are sufficient material on record to show that PW1, PW2 and PW3 had committed the offence punishable under Section 193 of IPC. Since, a complaint under Section 195 Code of Criminal Procedure is required to take cognizance for the offence punishable under Section 193 Indian Penal Code, this Court authorises Reader of the Court  i.e.Sh. Amit Sharma to file a complaint against PW1 (Renu), PW2 (Barkha) and PW3 (Kiran) on behalf of this Court for the offence punishable under Section 193 IPC before the Court of learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate. He is further directed to submit the compliance report within three weeks from the date of judgment.

Conclusion :-30.                 Inthe light of the above discussion, I hereby, acquit both the
accused persons, namely, Karnail Singh and Deepafrom all the charges.
Sh. Amit Sharma, Reader of this Court is authorised and directed to file a
complaint against the complainant PW1 (Renu) and her sisters PW2
(Barkha) and PW3 (Kiran) before the Court of learned Chief Metropolitan
Magistrate for the offence punishable under Section 193 of Indian Penal
Code and submit the compliance report within three weeks.
31.                 Filebe consigned to record room.
Announced in the open Court 
on this 19th day of May, 2014 
(PAWAN KUMAR JAIN) 
Additional Sessions Judge-01
Central district, Tis Hazari, Delhi/sm
SC No. 194/13 Page No. 15of 15

Source - http://judis.nic.in/